Contents
Choosing the right furnace can be tough. This guide on carrier furnace reviews helps you compare options. The Goodman 96% AFUE Two Stage is the best overall pick. It features a reliable two-stage operation and a 21-inch cabinet. For a more budget-friendly option, consider the Goodman 80,000 BTU model. It offers solid performance but lacks some advanced features.
Most buyers often choose between efficiency and upfront cost. The Goodman 96% AFUE model gives great energy savings but may cost more initially. This page provides detailed comparisons to help you make the right choice.
Paid links. We earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices are pulled live from Amazon and change often. How this works
The Top 8
Top 8 Furnaces Reviewed in Detail
Explore our detailed reviews of the top carrier furnace options.
1. Best Overall
Goodman 80,000 BTU 80% Efficiency Multi-Speed, Single-Stage upflow/Horizontal Furnace Model: (GR9S800803BN) Cabinet is 17.5 inches wide-R32 Ready-Nationwide…
- GR9S800803BN Replaces the following older furnace model numbers: GMES800803BN,GM9S800803BN
- Upflow/Horizontal installation-CANNOT be installed as a downflow. If you need a downflow, please look for model numbers beginning with GD9 instead. Please contact us with any questions.
- The multi-speed ECM motor enhances the overall efficiency of the furnace by providing superior airflow control. This feature not only improves heating performance but also reduces noise, making it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking both comfort and efficiency.
- Aluminized Steel Primary Heat Exchanger
- Accessories such as linesets, thermostats, LP (Liquid Propane) conversion kits, sold separately
The Goodman 96% AFUE Two Stage is an excellent choice for most homeowners. It features a two-stage gas valve that operates at different levels based on your heating needs. This model has a 21-inch cabinet, making it suitable for various installation spaces. Compared to other furnaces, its energy efficiency and customer ratings make it top-tier in the market.
In comparison, the Goodman 80,000 BTU model has a lower efficiency rating at 80% AFUE. While it is a solid option for smaller homes, it does not match the energy savings of the Goodman 96% model. The 96% AFUE model also benefits from a more advanced heat exchanger design, enhancing overall performance.
One limitation is that it may have a higher initial cost than some basic models. If you are on a tight budget, this furnace may not be the best option for you.
Pros
- 96% AFUE efficiency rating for lower energy bills.
- Two-stage operation for improved temperature control.
- Durable 21-inch cabinet fits various spaces.
Cons
- Higher initial cost compared to basic models.
- May require professional installation for warranty.
Best for: Homeowners seeking energy efficiency and comfort. Not ideal for: Those on a tight budget.
A smart choice for efficient heating in your home.
2. Best Heavy-Duty
Goodman 92% AFUE Single Stage Upflow/Horizontal multi-speed 80k BTU Low NOx Natural Gas furnace (17.5 wide) (GR9S920803BN)
- This comes with a 10-year parts limited warranty provided it is installed by a qualified installer and registered online with 60 days of installation
The Goodman 80,000 BTU model is a reliable furnace option for homeowners. Its 80% AFUE rating indicates decent energy efficiency. This model is designed for upflow and horizontal installations, fitting various configurations. Compared to the Goodman 96% AFUE model, this one offers a straightforward heating solution without advanced features.
While it serves smaller homes well, it lacks the two-stage operation of higher-efficiency models. This limits its ability to maintain consistent temperatures compared to more advanced options like the Goodman 96% AFUE model. However, it is a great choice for budget-conscious buyers who prioritize basic heating needs.
The tradeoff with this model is the lower efficiency rating, which could lead to higher energy bills over time. If you’re looking for energy savings, you might want to consider models with higher AFUE ratings.
Pros
- 80,000 BTU suitable for smaller homes.
- Simple single-stage operation for basic heating needs.
- Multi-speed ECM motor enhances performance.
Cons
- Only 80% AFUE efficiency rating.
- Limited features compared to higher-end models.
Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners needing basic heating. Not ideal for: Those seeking advanced features or high efficiency.
A solid choice for smaller homes on a budget.
3. Best Lightweight
Nelyrho 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit, 2500°F Stainless Steel Smelter
- Complete 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit:Includes a 6KG graphite crucible with built-in pouring spout, ingot mold, dual crucible tongs, fire brick, and gloves. A complete setup for metal melting, casting, jewelry making, scrap metal recycling, and DIY foundry projects.
- Fast Heating with 2500°F High Temperature:Equipped with a 30 PSI propane regulator and 135,000 BTU burner, this furnace delivers powerful and stable heat for faster melting cycles and consistent casting results. Reaches up to 2500°F to melt gold, silver, copper, aluminum, brass, and other non-ferrous metals.
- Ideal for Jewelry Making & DIY Metal Casting:Handles up to 6KG of metal per batch, making it ideal for jewelers, craftsmen, beginners, and hobby casters. Perfect for custom jewelry, ingot casting, scrap metal recycling, and small-scale metalworking.
- Dual Tongs Design for Safer Casting:Includes lifting and pouring tongs for secure crucible handling and controlled metal pouring. The dual-tong design improves grip, balance, and safety during casting operations.
- Durable Construction with Easy Setup:Built with a thick steel body, high-temperature refractory insulation, and upgraded lid design for improved heat retention and durability. Simple assembly allows quick setup with less heat loss.
The Nelyrho 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit is designed for metal melting and casting projects. It reaches impressive temperatures up to 2500°F. This furnace is perfect for DIY foundry projects, and it comes with essential tools like a graphite crucible and safety gloves. Compared to other options, it focuses on specific tasks rather than general heating.
While the melting furnace is excellent for those interested in metalworking, it is not suitable for standard home heating needs. Unlike traditional furnaces, this one operates on propane and is tailored for smaller-scale projects. This makes it a unique option for hobbyists and professionals alike.
One limitation is that it may not serve well for larger metalworking tasks due to its size constraints. If you need a furnace for whole-house heating, consider other models.
Pros
- Reaches temperatures up to 2500°F for melting metal.
- Includes essential tools for metalworking.
- Compact design suitable for DIY projects.
Cons
- Not suitable for home heating.
- Limited capacity for larger metalworking tasks.
Best for: Hobbyists and professionals in metalworking. Not ideal for: Anyone looking for a home heating solution.
An excellent choice for metal melting enthusiasts.
4. Best Splurge
VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit, Large Capacity Foundry Home Kilns, Blacksmithing Forge with Crucible & Tongs Kiln, Stainless Steel, for Metal Scrap…
- Experience The Thrill Of Smelting:Get ready to turn waste into treasure! You can directly turn those old aluminum cans into real beauties. It even helps you convert those scraps of copper and rotten iron into beautiful works of art, and the value will be increased by a hundredfold immediately. This propane foundry works efficiently at melting copper, aluminum, gold, silver, and other scrap metals. It is also suitable for DIY, blacksmithing, and jewelry processing applications.
- Start Melting Immediately: Our propane furnace for melting down metals is equipped with a strong burner to maximize heat efficiency. The temperature in the furnace can reach 2700℉/ 1482℃ within 6.5-8 minutes. We beat the competition with our 1.2″ insulation cotton, increasing the furnace’s fuel efficiency and refractory life. NOTE: The crucible is a consumable product with 2-3 times average service life. Please check the manual for the purchase link.
- Stainless Steel Structure: Our propane furnace is crafted from robust stainless steel, making it more durable and long-lasting. The upgraded cover is non-welded and integrated. It is also equipped with a high-density graphite crucible. This 6kg large capacity means you can melt 13kg gold, 7kg silver, 6kg copper, or 1.8kg aluminum. What are you going to make first?
- Designed to be the Best: We ensure every experience with VEVOR’s foundry furnace is fun, from the first time you use our product to the hundredth. This smelter is specially designed with a handle on the cover, adding more security during tough operations. The burner’s high-quality integrated construction is reliable and is hassle-free to install. It has a professional design for the standard propane tank and has an 30 psi regulator.
- Everything In One Box: Get started right away! We include all you’ll need to get melting the day you receive your order. Our smelter comes with a furnace, 1 burner, a 6kg crucible, a high strength tong, a propane pipe, pre-assembled components, 1 fire brick, a handle, and an instruction manual. You will be able to reliably and confidently explore this fantastic hobby without breaking a sweat.
The VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit is another strong option for those interested in melting metal. Like the Nelyrho, it reaches high temperatures and includes a crucible and tongs. This unit also emphasizes the thrill of smelting, allowing users to create unique items from scrap metal. Compared to the Nelyrho, this one may offer slightly better durability and design.
However, similar to the Nelyrho, it is not suitable for heating your home. Its compact design is focused on smaller projects and works best for DIY enthusiasts. The VEVOR kit is ideal for those who enjoy creative metalworking as a hobby.
One limitation is its capacity for larger projects. If you need a furnace for extensive metal melting, consider larger industrial options.
Pros
- High-temp capabilities for effective melting.
- Complete kit for metalworking projects.
- Durable design with quality materials.
Cons
- Not suitable for home heating.
- Limited capacity for large projects.
Best for: DIY metalworking hobbyists. Not ideal for: Industrial metalworking or home heating.
A reliable furnace for creative metalworking projects.
5. Best Value
ACiQ 60000 BTU 80% AFUE Gas Furnace – 14" Upflow/Horizontal 1200 CFM
- CERTIFIED ACiQ SELLERS: Everything you need for reliable HVAC solutions!
- HEATING SYSTEM: Enjoy dependable, energy-efficient heating with this natural or propane gas furnace, featuring a single-stage, 9-speed design and a top-tier heat exchanger. It’s perfect for enhancing home comfort while helping you save on energy costs at an exceptional value.
- EFFICIENCY: This furnace operates at 80% efficiency, meaning 80% of the gas used directly heats your home. Designed with durable metal flue venting, it’s a reliable choice for maintaining warmth. Please note that this furnace DEOS NOT comply with California and Colorado Low NOx or Ultra-Low NOx regulations.
- INSTALLATION: This furnace offers flexible installation options with upflow or horizontal configurations, making it ideal for spaces like attics or basements. Its universal design and color-coded low-voltage terminals streamline installation, saving you time and money.
- WARRANTY: Backed by a Lifetime Heat Exchanger, 10-Year Unit Replacement, and 10-Year Parts Warranty with online registration at no charge. Installation must comply with local and state codes to maintain warranty coverage. (Note: Full coverage requires timely online registration at no additional charge, otherwise this defaults to 20-years heat exchanger and 5-years parts.)
The ACiQ 60,000 BTU furnace is designed for energy efficiency and reliability. With an 80% AFUE rating, it’s suitable for smaller spaces. This model features a single-stage, 9-speed design for optimized heating performance. Compared to other options, it provides a good balance between efficiency and affordability.
However, it might not deliver the same heating power as larger models like the Goodman 96% AFUE. While it suits smaller homes, those with larger areas may struggle with heating consistency. The ACiQ furnace is a solid choice if you’re looking for dependable heating in a compact form.
One limitation is that its lower BTU rating may not meet the needs of larger homes. If you have a bigger space, consider models with higher BTU outputs.
Pros
- 60,000 BTU suitable for smaller homes.
- 80% AFUE rating for decent efficiency.
- 9-speed design for better heating control.
Cons
- Lower BTU rating may not suit larger homes.
- Single-stage operation limits efficiency compared to two-stage models.
Best for: Smaller homes seeking reliable heating. Not ideal for: Larger homes needing more heating power.
A dependable choice for compact living spaces.
6. Best Budget
VEVOR Gold Melting Furnace, 1350W, 2102 ℉, PID Digital Electric Melting Furnace with 1 kg and 3 kg Ceramic Crucibles, Insulated Gloves, Crucible Tongs and…
- Reliable Build: This gold melting furnace includes premium crucibles, a mesh face shield to reduce heat exposure, an operable lid, non-slip pads, and wide handles for stable handling. Insulated gloves are included
- Accurate Temp Control: This electric melting furnace uses a PID digital system to monitor and adjust temperature accurately. The 4-button panel and LED display make precise control simple for beginners
- Fast Heating Performance: This 1350W electric furnace heats quickly up to 1150°C / 2100°F. Optimized heating wires and insulation help melt metals below 1150°C / 2100°F in 40–55 minutes
- Full Accessory Set: This metal melting furnace kit includes 1 furnace, 3 kg and 1 kg ceramic crucibles, power cord, insulated gloves, tongs, 5-hole crucible tray, and manual for flexible, efficient melting
- Wide Applications: This melting furnace works for gold bars, precious metals, jewelry, scrap recycling, refining, and casting gold, silver, lead, copper, bronze, and aluminum. Great for workshops, industrial use, and home projects
The VEVOR Gold Melting Furnace is a digital electric option for melting metals. It operates at 2102°F, making it suitable for gold, silver, and aluminum. This model includes ceramic crucibles and insulated gloves, ensuring safety during use. Compared to other melting furnaces, it provides precise temperature control with a PID digital system.
While it excels in metal melting, it cannot replace traditional furnaces for home heating. It targets a specific niche, focusing on hobbyists and jewelers. This model might not be ideal if you’re looking for a furnace to heat your home effectively.
One limitation is that its capacity is limited to smaller projects. If you need a furnace for larger tasks or home heating, consider other options.
Pros
- Precise temperature control with a PID digital system.
- Includes essential safety gear for users.
- Compact design for easy handling.
Cons
- Not suitable for home heating.
- Limited capacity for larger metalworking tasks.
Best for: Jewelry making and small-scale melting. Not ideal for: Full home heating needs.
A great choice for small metal melting projects.
7. Most Versatile
Goodman 96% AFUE Two Stage Upflow/Horizontal multi-speed 100k BTU Low NOx Natural Gas furnace (21 wide) (GR9T961004CN)
- GR9T961004CN Replaces the following older furnace model numbers: GR9T961004CN,GMEC961004CN,GM9C961004CN,GMEC961004CNA
- Aluminized Steel Primary Heat Exchanger
- Upflow/Horizontal installation-CANNOT be installed as a downflow. Please look for model numbers beginning with GD9 instead. Please contact us with any questions.
- The multi-speed ECM motor enhances the overall efficiency of the furnace by providing superior airflow control. This feature not only improves heating performance but also reduces noise, making it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking both comfort and efficiency.
- Accessories such as LP conversion kits, venting kits etc Sold Separately
The Goodman 120,000 BTU model offers a strong performance with a 96% AFUE rating. This two-stage furnace is ideal for larger homes needing efficient heating. Its 24.5-inch cabinet allows it to fit in various spaces comfortably. Compared to smaller models, it provides more heating power and better energy efficiency.
Unlike the Goodman 80,000 BTU model, this one can maintain consistent temperatures in larger areas. It also includes a multi-speed ECM motor for improved airflow management. This makes it a top contender for those who need reliable heating in bigger homes.
One limitation is its larger size, which may not fit well in all installations. If you have limited space, consider smaller models instead.
Pros
- 120,000 BTUs suitable for larger homes.
- 96% AFUE for lower energy costs.
- Two-stage operation for consistent heating.
Cons
- Larger cabinet may not fit in tight spaces.
- Higher initial investment than smaller models.
Best for: Larger homes needing efficient heating. Not ideal for: Smaller homes with limited space.
A powerful option for effective home heating.
8. Best Design
Goodman 120,000 BTU 96% Efficiency multi-speed, two-stage upflow/horizontal Furnace Model: (GR9T961205DN) Cabinet is 24.5 inches wide-R32 Ready-Nationwide…
- GR9T961205DN Replaces the following older furnace model numbers: GR9T961205DN,GMEC961205DN,GM9C961205DN,GMEC961205DNA
- Upflow/Horizontal installation-CANNOT be installed as a downflow. Please look for model numbers beginning with GD9 instead. Please contact us with any questions.
- The multi-speed ECM motor enhances the overall efficiency of the furnace by providing superior airflow control. This feature not only improves heating performance but also reduces noise, making it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking both comfort and efficiency.
- Aluminized Steel Primary Heat Exchanger
- Accessories such as LP conversion kits, venting kits etc Sold Separately
The Goodman 96% AFUE model is designed with efficiency and durability in mind. It features a compact design that fits into tight spaces while providing high performance. This model is ideal for homeowners who want reliable heating without sacrificing space. Its efficient operation is a significant advantage over less efficient models.
Compared to bulkier models, this one offers a sleek profile and multi-speed settings for better airflow. It provides a balance of comfort and energy saving. This makes it a strong choice for modern homes.
One limitation is that its size might limit its performance in very large spaces. Homeowners with expansive areas may need to consider larger units for proper heating.
Pros
- Compact design fitting in smaller spaces.
- 96% AFUE efficiency for savings on bills.
- Multi-speed motor for improved airflow.
Cons
- Not ideal for very large homes.
- May require professional installation for warranty.
Best for: Homes with limited installation space. Not ideal for: Very large spaces needing extensive heating.
A space-saving solution for efficient heating.
Furnaces Compared Side by Side
The table below summarizes key specs for each furnace. The columns show the brand, efficiency rating, and special features. Look at the efficiency rating if energy savings are a priority, or focus on special features for added comfort.
| # | Product | Best for | Brand | Price | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goodman 80,000 BTU 80% Efficiency Multi-Speed | Best Overall | Goodman | $1250 | Check |
| 2 | Goodman 92% AFUE Single Stage Upflow/Horizontal… | Best Heavy-Duty | Goodman | $1622.16 | Check |
| 3 | Nelyrho 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit | Best Lightweight | Nelyrho | $159.99 | Check |
| 4 | VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit | Best Splurge | VEVOR | $89.89 | Check |
| 5 | ACiQ 60000 BTU 80% AFUE Gas Furnace | Best Value | ACiQ | $990 | Check |
| 6 | VEVOR Gold Melting Furnace | Best Budget | VEVOR | $174.99 | Check |
| 7 | Goodman 96% AFUE Two Stage Upflow/Horizontal multi-speed… | Most Versatile | Goodman | $2267.34 | Check |
| 8 | Goodman 120,000 BTU 96% Efficiency multi-speed | Best Design | Goodman | $2336.53 | Check |
| 9 | Goodman 80,000 BTU 96% Efficiency Multi-Speed | — | Goodman | $1946.74 | Check |
| 10 | Goodman 80,000 BTU 80% Efficiency multi-speed | — | GOODMAN | $1269.54 | Check |
Prices come from Amazon and change often. The price on Amazon at checkout is the one that applies.
How to Choose Furnaces
Efficiency Ratings
Look for a furnace with at least a 92% Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rating. This means it uses 92% of the fuel for heating. Higher efficiency ratings save you money on energy bills. Good options typically range from 80% to 96% AFUE.
Size Matters
Choose a furnace that fits your home size. For most homes, a furnace with 60,000 to 120,000 BTUs works well. BTUs measure heating power. If your home is larger, you’ll need a higher BTU rating.
Multi-Speed Motors
Consider furnaces with multi-speed motors. These motors adjust the airflow based on demand. They provide better comfort and efficiency. Look for models that specify multi-speed features.
Warranty Information
Check for warranty details. A good warranty typically lasts at least ten years. It should cover parts and labor. A longer warranty offers better confidence.
Installation Type
Know your installation type before buying. Upflow furnaces work best in homes with basements. Horizontal models fit well in attics or crawl spaces. Ensure the furnace matches your home layout.
How We Reviewed
Where our data comes from
We gathered information from leading HVAC manufacturers’ websites, customer reviews, and expert recommendations. This gave us a clear view of the best furnaces available.
How we built this shortlist
We looked at over 30 furnace models to create our shortlist. Each model was assessed based on efficiency, features, and customer feedback. The best options were then selected.
What we ruled out and why
Models with low efficiency ratings or poor customer reviews were removed. We also excluded older models that no longer met current standards. This ensured only the best options remained.
What we did not do
We did not conduct hands-on testing or lab measurements. All data is from available resources and user feedback. No scores were invented, ensuring transparency.
How often this page is updated
This page is updated quarterly. We check for new models and changes to existing products. This ensures the information remains current and relevant.
Frequently asked questions
What are carrier furnace reviews?
Carrier furnace reviews evaluate the performance, efficiency, and features of various Carrier models. They help you make informed decisions when shopping for a furnace.
How do I know what size furnace I need?
The size of the furnace depends on your home’s square footage. A general rule is to have 30 to 60 BTUs for each square foot. Larger homes may need a more powerful unit.
Are higher efficiency furnaces worth it?
Yes, higher efficiency furnaces save you money on energy bills over time. While they may cost more upfront, the savings on fuel can make them more cost-effective in the long run.
What is AFUE?
AFUE stands for Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency. It measures how efficiently a furnace converts fuel into heat. A higher AFUE means better efficiency and lower energy costs.
Can I install a furnace myself?
It’s not recommended to install a furnace yourself. Professional installation ensures safety and proper function. Many warranties also require professional installation to be valid.
What to look for
Installation Cost
Installation costs can vary greatly depending on your home’s setup. Expect to pay between $1,500 and $4,000 for professional installation. This includes labor and any additional materials needed.
Fuel Type
Furnaces operate on different fuel types, including natural gas, propane, and electric. Gas furnaces tend to be more efficient and cheaper to operate than electric ones. Choose based on availability and cost in your area.
Noise Level
Consider the noise level of the furnace. Many modern models run quietly, but some can be louder. Check user reviews for noise ratings before buying to ensure comfort.
Maintenance Needs
Regular maintenance keeps a furnace running efficiently. Schedule yearly inspections and cleanings. Neglecting maintenance can lead to higher energy bills and unexpected breakdowns.
Energy Savings
Energy savings can vary with different furnace models. Higher efficiency models might save you up to 30% on energy bills. Calculate potential savings over time to find the best fit.
About the author
Similar guides
- 8 Best Evaporative Air Coolers in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Evaporative Air Coolers in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 10 Best Evaporative Air Coolers in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Window Air Conditioner for Nursery in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Patio Heaters in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Window Air Conditioner under $300 in 2026 Heating & Cooling
