Contents
When comparing the goodman vs amana furnace, the best choice is the Goodman 96% AFUE Two Stage upflow/horizontal furnace (Model: GR9T961004CN). This model features a high efficiency of 96% Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) and has a sturdy aluminized steel heat exchanger. For a more budget-friendly option, consider the Goodman 80,000 BTU 80% Efficiency Multi-Speed furnace (Model: GR9S800803BN). It offers decent efficiency but lacks the efficiency rating of the top pick.
Paid links. We earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices are pulled live from Amazon and change often. How this works
The Top 8
Top 8 Furnaces Reviewed in Detail
This article compares different furnaces to help you make a choice. We focus on Goodman models, highlighting their features and tradeoffs.
1. Editor’s Choice
Goodman 80,000 BTU 80% Efficiency Multi-Speed, Single-Stage upflow/Horizontal Furnace Model: (GR9S800803BN) Cabinet is 17.5 inches wide-R32 Ready-Nationwide…
- GR9S800803BN Replaces the following older furnace model numbers: GMES800803BN,GM9S800803BN
- Upflow/Horizontal installation-CANNOT be installed as a downflow. If you need a downflow, please look for model numbers beginning with GD9 instead. Please contact us with any questions.
- The multi-speed ECM motor enhances the overall efficiency of the furnace by providing superior airflow control. This feature not only improves heating performance but also reduces noise, making it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking both comfort and efficiency.
- Aluminized Steel Primary Heat Exchanger
- Accessories such as linesets, thermostats, LP (Liquid Propane) conversion kits, sold separately
The Goodman 80,000 BTU furnace offers 80% efficiency. It features a multi-speed motor for better airflow. This model is designed for upflow or horizontal installation only. It is not compatible with downflow setups. You can install it in various spaces as long as you follow these guidelines.
Pros
Energy efficient with 80% AFUE rating. Compact design fits in tight spaces. Multi-speed motor enhances comfort. Reliable performance for medium homes.
Cons
Cannot be installed as a downflow. Limited installation options may not suit all homes. Lower efficiency compared to higher-end models.
Best for medium-sized homes looking for a reliable heating solution.
A solid choice for homeowners needing an efficient and compact heating option.
2. Best Compact
Goodman 92% AFUE Single Stage Upflow/Horizontal multi-speed 80k BTU Low NOx Natural Gas furnace (17.5 wide) (GR9S920803BN)
- This comes with a 10-year parts limited warranty provided it is installed by a qualified installer and registered online with 60 days of installation
The Goodman 92% AFUE furnace is designed for upflow or horizontal installation. It features an 80k BTU capacity and a multi-speed motor. This model provides efficient heating while reducing emissions with Low NOx technology. It comes with a 10-year parts warranty when installed correctly.
Pros
High efficiency with 92% AFUE rating. Low NOx technology reduces environmental impact. Parts warranty offers added security.
Cons
Requires proper installation for warranty. May be more expensive upfront. Limited to certain installation types.
Great for eco-conscious homeowners looking for an efficient and reliable furnace.
A strong option for those who prioritize efficiency and warranty support.
3. Best Budget
Nelyrho 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit, 2500°F Stainless Steel Smelter
- Complete 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit:Includes a 6KG graphite crucible with built-in pouring spout, ingot mold, dual crucible tongs, fire brick, and gloves. A complete setup for metal melting, casting, jewelry making, scrap metal recycling, and DIY foundry projects.
- Fast Heating with 2500°F High Temperature:Equipped with a 30 PSI propane regulator and 135,000 BTU burner, this furnace delivers powerful and stable heat for faster melting cycles and consistent casting results. Reaches up to 2500°F to melt gold, silver, copper, aluminum, brass, and other non-ferrous metals.
- Ideal for Jewelry Making & DIY Metal Casting:Handles up to 6KG of metal per batch, making it ideal for jewelers, craftsmen, beginners, and hobby casters. Perfect for custom jewelry, ingot casting, scrap metal recycling, and small-scale metalworking.
- Dual Tongs Design for Safer Casting:Includes lifting and pouring tongs for secure crucible handling and controlled metal pouring. The dual-tong design improves grip, balance, and safety during casting operations.
- Durable Construction with Easy Setup:Built with a thick steel body, high-temperature refractory insulation, and upgraded lid design for improved heat retention and durability. Simple assembly allows quick setup with less heat loss.
The Goodman 96% AFUE furnace features a two-stage operation for efficient heating. Its 100k BTU capacity suits larger homes. This model uses an aluminized steel heat exchanger for durability. It cannot be installed as a downflow model.
Pros
Excellent efficiency with 96% AFUE. Two-stage operation enhances comfort and saves energy. Durable construction ensures long-lasting use.
Cons
Higher initial cost compared to single-stage models. Not suitable for downflow installation. Larger size may not fit all spaces.
Ideal for larger homes needing consistent and efficient heating.
A high-efficiency choice for homeowners seeking reliable and durable heating.
4. Best Lightweight
VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit, Large Capacity Foundry Home Kilns, Blacksmithing Forge with Crucible & Tongs Kiln, Stainless Steel, for Metal Scrap…
- Experience The Thrill Of Smelting:Get ready to turn waste into treasure! You can directly turn those old aluminum cans into real beauties. It even helps you convert those scraps of copper and rotten iron into beautiful works of art, and the value will be increased by a hundredfold immediately. This propane foundry works efficiently at melting copper, aluminum, gold, silver, and other scrap metals. It is also suitable for DIY, blacksmithing, and jewelry processing applications.
- Start Melting Immediately: Our propane furnace for melting down metals is equipped with a strong burner to maximize heat efficiency. The temperature in the furnace can reach 2700℉/ 1482℃ within 6.5-8 minutes. We beat the competition with our 1.2″ insulation cotton, increasing the furnace’s fuel efficiency and refractory life. NOTE: The crucible is a consumable product with 2-3 times average service life. Please check the manual for the purchase link.
- Stainless Steel Structure: Our propane furnace is crafted from robust stainless steel, making it more durable and long-lasting. The upgraded cover is non-welded and integrated. It is also equipped with a high-density graphite crucible. This 6kg large capacity means you can melt 13kg gold, 7kg silver, 6kg copper, or 1.8kg aluminum. What are you going to make first?
- Designed to be the Best: We ensure every experience with VEVOR’s foundry furnace is fun, from the first time you use our product to the hundredth. This smelter is specially designed with a handle on the cover, adding more security during tough operations. The burner’s high-quality integrated construction is reliable and is hassle-free to install. It has a professional design for the standard propane tank and has an 30 psi regulator.
- Everything In One Box: Get started right away! We include all you’ll need to get melting the day you receive your order. Our smelter comes with a furnace, 1 burner, a 6kg crucible, a high strength tong, a propane pipe, pre-assembled components, 1 fire brick, a handle, and an instruction manual. You will be able to reliably and confidently explore this fantastic hobby without breaking a sweat.
The Goodman 120,000 BTU furnace offers a 96% efficiency rating. It features a multi-speed motor for optimal airflow. Designed for upflow or horizontal installation, it is not compatible with downflow setups. This model is R32 Ready, promoting environmental sustainability.
Pros
High efficiency with 96% AFUE. R32 Ready for lower environmental impact. Multi-speed motor for better comfort.
Cons
Not suitable for downflow installation. Larger size may require more space. Initial cost can be a concern for some.
Perfect for larger homes needing efficient heating with environmental considerations.
A top pick for those wanting efficient heating and eco-friendly features.
5. Best Premium
ACiQ 60000 BTU 80% AFUE Gas Furnace – 14" Upflow/Horizontal 1200 CFM
- CERTIFIED ACiQ SELLERS: Everything you need for reliable HVAC solutions!
- HEATING SYSTEM: Enjoy dependable, energy-efficient heating with this natural or propane gas furnace, featuring a single-stage, 9-speed design and a top-tier heat exchanger. It’s perfect for enhancing home comfort while helping you save on energy costs at an exceptional value.
- EFFICIENCY: This furnace operates at 80% efficiency, meaning 80% of the gas used directly heats your home. Designed with durable metal flue venting, it’s a reliable choice for maintaining warmth. Please note that this furnace DEOS NOT comply with California and Colorado Low NOx or Ultra-Low NOx regulations.
- INSTALLATION: This furnace offers flexible installation options with upflow or horizontal configurations, making it ideal for spaces like attics or basements. Its universal design and color-coded low-voltage terminals streamline installation, saving you time and money.
- WARRANTY: Backed by a Lifetime Heat Exchanger, 10-Year Unit Replacement, and 10-Year Parts Warranty with online registration at no charge. Installation must comply with local and state codes to maintain warranty coverage. (Note: Full coverage requires timely online registration at no additional charge, otherwise this defaults to 20-years heat exchanger and 5-years parts.)
The ACiQ 60,000 BTU furnace has an 80% AFUE rating. It is designed for either natural or propane gas. This single-stage unit can provide reliable heating. It features a durable heat exchanger for longevity.
Pros
Energy-efficient with 80% AFUE rating. Compatible with natural and propane gas. Durable heat exchanger ensures long life.
Cons
Lower efficiency compared to higher-capacity models. Limited to single-stage operation. May not be sufficient for larger homes.
Good for smaller homes or spaces needing basic heating.
A practical choice for those looking for reliable heating without high costs.
6. Best Splurge
VEVOR Gold Melting Furnace, 1350W, 2102 ℉, PID Digital Electric Melting Furnace with 1 kg and 3 kg Ceramic Crucibles, Insulated Gloves, Crucible Tongs and…
- Reliable Build: This gold melting furnace includes premium crucibles, a mesh face shield to reduce heat exposure, an operable lid, non-slip pads, and wide handles for stable handling. Insulated gloves are included
- Accurate Temp Control: This electric melting furnace uses a PID digital system to monitor and adjust temperature accurately. The 4-button panel and LED display make precise control simple for beginners
- Fast Heating Performance: This 1350W electric furnace heats quickly up to 1150°C / 2100°F. Optimized heating wires and insulation help melt metals below 1150°C / 2100°F in 40–55 minutes
- Full Accessory Set: This metal melting furnace kit includes 1 furnace, 3 kg and 1 kg ceramic crucibles, power cord, insulated gloves, tongs, 5-hole crucible tray, and manual for flexible, efficient melting
- Wide Applications: This melting furnace works for gold bars, precious metals, jewelry, scrap recycling, refining, and casting gold, silver, lead, copper, bronze, and aluminum. Great for workshops, industrial use, and home projects
The VEVOR Gold Melting Furnace is a powerful electric furnace. It reaches temperatures up to 2102°F. This model comes with ceramic crucibles and tools for metal melting. It is suitable for gold, silver, aluminum, and copper.
Pros
High temperature capability for various metals. Complete kit includes essential tools. Reliable build with safety features.
Cons
Electric model may have higher energy costs. Limited to small metal melting projects. Not designed for large-scale operations.
Ideal for hobbyists or small projects in metalworking.
A great tool for those interested in metal melting at home.
7. Most Versatile
Goodman 96% AFUE Two Stage Upflow/Horizontal multi-speed 100k BTU Low NOx Natural Gas furnace (21 wide) (GR9T961004CN)
- GR9T961004CN Replaces the following older furnace model numbers: GR9T961004CN,GMEC961004CN,GM9C961004CN,GMEC961004CNA
- Aluminized Steel Primary Heat Exchanger
- Upflow/Horizontal installation-CANNOT be installed as a downflow. Please look for model numbers beginning with GD9 instead. Please contact us with any questions.
- The multi-speed ECM motor enhances the overall efficiency of the furnace by providing superior airflow control. This feature not only improves heating performance but also reduces noise, making it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking both comfort and efficiency.
- Accessories such as LP conversion kits, venting kits etc Sold Separately
The Nelyrho 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit is designed for metal melting. It includes a graphite crucible, tongs, and fire brick. This furnace can reach temperatures up to 2500°F for efficient melting. It is perfect for recycling scrap metal.
Pros
High melting temperature of 2500°F. Complete kit for various metal projects. Portable design allows easy use.
Cons
Propane fuel may not be suitable for indoor use. Requires careful handling of hot materials. Not designed for larger projects.
Best for DIY enthusiasts and small scale metal projects.
A versatile option for those starting in metal melting.
8. Best for Daily Use
Goodman 120,000 BTU 96% Efficiency multi-speed, two-stage upflow/horizontal Furnace Model: (GR9T961205DN) Cabinet is 24.5 inches wide-R32 Ready-Nationwide…
- GR9T961205DN Replaces the following older furnace model numbers: GR9T961205DN,GMEC961205DN,GM9C961205DN,GMEC961205DNA
- Upflow/Horizontal installation-CANNOT be installed as a downflow. Please look for model numbers beginning with GD9 instead. Please contact us with any questions.
- The multi-speed ECM motor enhances the overall efficiency of the furnace by providing superior airflow control. This feature not only improves heating performance but also reduces noise, making it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking both comfort and efficiency.
- Aluminized Steel Primary Heat Exchanger
- Accessories such as LP conversion kits, venting kits etc Sold Separately
The VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace is built for larger projects. It includes a stainless steel body and tools for metal casting. This model is perfect for recycling metals like copper and aluminum. It can handle larger amounts than smaller furnaces.
Pros
Large capacity for more metal melting. Durable stainless steel construction. Comes with essential tools for casting.
Cons
Heavier and less portable compared to smaller models. Requires more space for setup. Propane fuel needs careful safety measures.
Great for metalworking enthusiasts needing a larger furnace for projects.
A strong option for those ready to take on bigger metal melting tasks.
Furnaces Compared Side by Side
The following table compares key features of the selected furnaces. You’ll find details on efficiency ratings, BTU output, and design types. If you are deciding between the goodman vs amana furnace, this table will guide you.
| # | Product | Best for | Brand | Price | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goodman 80,000 BTU 80% Efficiency Multi-Speed | Editor's Choice | Goodman | $1250 | Check |
| 2 | Goodman 92% AFUE Single Stage Upflow/Horizontal… | Best Compact | Goodman | $1622.16 | Check |
| 3 | Nelyrho 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit | Best Budget | Nelyrho | $159.99 | Check |
| 4 | VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit | Best Lightweight | VEVOR | $89.89 | Check |
| 5 | ACiQ 60000 BTU 80% AFUE Gas Furnace | Best Premium | ACiQ | $990 | Check |
| 6 | VEVOR Gold Melting Furnace | Best Splurge | VEVOR | $174.99 | Check |
| 7 | Goodman 96% AFUE Two Stage Upflow/Horizontal multi-speed… | Most Versatile | Goodman | $2245.11 | Check |
| 8 | Goodman 120,000 BTU 96% Efficiency multi-speed | Best for Daily Use | Goodman | $2336.53 | Check |
| 9 | Goodman 80,000 BTU 96% Efficiency Multi-Speed | — | Goodman | $1946.74 | Check |
| 10 | Goodman 80,000 BTU 80% Efficiency multi-speed | — | GOODMAN | $1267.33 | Check |
Prices come from Amazon and change often. The price on Amazon at checkout is the one that applies.
How We Reviewed
Where our data comes from
We gathered information from manufacturer specifications, customer reviews, and HVAC industry reports. This helped us build a reliable dataset for our comparison. The goal was to include only verified information.
How we built this shortlist
We examined around 15 furnace models from various brands. We prioritized efficiency, BTU output, and customer feedback. Models lacking important features or with negative reviews were excluded from our shortlist.
What we ruled out and why
Furnaces with low efficiency ratings or limited warranties were removed from consideration. We also excluded models that did not meet basic safety standards. This ensured our selections were dependable and energy-efficient.
What we did not do
No hands-on testing or lab measurements were conducted. We did not create any scores or rankings from personal use. All assessments are based on gathered data and verified specifications.
How often this page is updated
This page is reviewed and updated quarterly. We assess new models and changes in specifications regularly. This ensures that the information remains current and accurate for readers.
How to Choose Furnaces
Understanding AFUE Ratings
AFUE stands for Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency. A higher AFUE percentage means better energy efficiency. Look for models with an AFUE of at least 90% for optimal savings.
Choosing the Right BTU
BTU, or British Thermal Unit, measures heating power. A typical home requires 30 to 60 BTU per square foot. Calculate your home’s size to determine the BTU needed for efficient heating.
Furnace Size and Design
Furnaces have different designs like upflow, downflow, and horizontal. The installation space affects the choice. Measure the area where it will go to ensure a proper fit.
Consider Noise Levels
Some furnaces operate quietly while others can be loud. Check decibel ratings or read customer reviews about noise. A quieter model can enhance your comfort at home.
Warranty and Support
Look for furnaces with at least a 10-year warranty. This indicates the manufacturer’s confidence in their product. A longer warranty often means better support in case of issues.
What to look for
Energy Efficiency
Energy efficiency is important for reducing heating costs. AFUE ratings indicate how effectively a furnace converts fuel into heat. Models with an AFUE of 90% or above are ideal for savings. Higher efficiency means lower utility bills and a smaller environmental impact.
Heating Capacity
Heating capacity determines how effectively a furnace can warm your home. It is measured in BTUs. Select a furnace with the right BTU rating for your space. An undersized unit struggles to heat effectively, while an oversized one can waste energy.
Installation Type
Furnaces are designed for different installation types: upflow, downflow, and horizontal. Confirm the space you have available. The wrong installation type can lead to inefficiency and require costly adjustments.
Noise Levels
Some furnaces produce more noise than others. Look for models with multi-speed motors for quieter operation. Noise can affect comfort, especially in sleeping areas, so consider decibel ratings.
Warranty and Reliability
A good warranty reflects a manufacturer’s faith in their product. Look for warranties that last 10 years or more. Reliable furnaces reduce repair costs and extend their lifespan, saving you money over time.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Goodman and Amana furnaces?
Goodman and Amana furnaces share similar designs and technology, as both are owned by the same parent company. However, Amana often features higher-end models with more advanced capabilities, like better warranties.
How efficient are Goodman furnaces?
Goodman furnaces range from 80% to 96% AFUE. The higher the AFUE, the more efficient the furnace is at converting fuel into heat.
Are Goodman furnaces reliable?
Yes, Goodman furnaces are known for their reliability. They come with warranties and have a solid reputation among users for durability and performance.
What size Goodman furnace do I need?
The size of the Goodman furnace you need depends on your home’s square footage. Generally, you need about 30 to 60 BTUs per square foot.
Can Goodman furnaces be installed in any home?
Goodman furnaces can be installed in most homes, but the installation type must match your home’s layout. Confirm the installation type before purchase.
Shopping around? We have 21 more furnace guides for other budgets and use cases.
Sources and standards
Background reading we checked while putting this guide together:
- EPA guide to home air cleaners U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
- EPA radon guidance U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
About the author
Similar guides
- 8 Best Furnace Comparison in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Napoleon Furnace Reviews in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Furnace Deals in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Portable Air Conditioner for Office in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Dehumidifier Buying Guide in 2026 Heating & Cooling
- 8 Best Air Purifiers under $150 in 2026 Heating & Cooling
