Contents
Choosing the right eyeliner can be tough. For the eyeliner comparison, NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Eyeliner is our top pick. Its waterproof matte finish lasts up to 24 hours and has a precise tip for control. Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a great value choice, but it lacks the ultra-fine application of our top pick. Many buyers face the tradeoff between ease of use and longevity. NYX offers a longer wear while Revlon is easier for quick applications. This page will help you weigh your options clearly.
Paid links. We earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices are pulled live from Amazon and change often. How this works
The Top 8
Top 8 Eyeliners Reviewed in Detail
Here are the best eyeliners on the market today, each with unique features to consider.
1. Editor’s Choice
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HR Wear, Black
- Waterproof Matte Liquid Eyeliner: Get the perfect long lasting cat eye look with NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink eyeliner, with a matte black finish
- Precise Tip: Our ultra precise tip is flexible and Easy to Use; Every stroke is unbelievably fluid for a defined finish; Control the thickness of your lines by pressing down just a touch; Fine and natural, broad and bold, the look is always up to you
- All Eyes On Eye Makeup: Complete your look with our full range of eye makeup products ranging from eyeshadow palettes to false eyelashes, eyeliners, concealers, setting sprays, eyebrow makeup, eyeshadow primer and more
- Cruelty Free Cosmetics: We believe animals belong in our arms, not in a lab; All of our makeup is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty free brand; We don’t test any of our products on animals
- Discover NYX Professional Makeup: Try all of our professional makeup products today from eyeshadow, eyeliner, and false lashes to liquid lipstick, lip gloss, primer, concealer, setting sprays and eyebrow makeup
- 2025 Allure Best of Beauty Winner
NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Eyeliner is our top pick for its waterproof matte finish and up to 24-hour wear. The precise tip allows for smooth and controlled application. This eyeliner creates a defined look, perfect for a cat eye or subtle lines. Compared to the other options, it offers superior longevity. While other eyeliners can smudge or fade, this one remains intact throughout the day. A noted limitation is that it may not be as easy to remove as some pencil options, requiring a good makeup remover. However, for those who prioritize lasting wear, it is an excellent choice.
Pros
- Waterproof for long-lasting wear
- Matte finish for a trendy look
- Precise tip for detailed application
Cons
- May require strong makeup remover
- Not the easiest for beginners
- Can be too bold for some users
Best for: Users seeking a long-lasting eyeliner. Not ideal for: Those who prefer a quick and easy removal.
A reliable choice for long-lasting, defined looks.
2. Best Splurge
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 201 Black, 2 pack
- LASTING EYELINER: Rich color looks freshly applied all day long; transfer-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof and fade-proof
- UP TO 24HR WEAR: Creates the look you want and stays on strong
- EASY APPLICATION: Pencil eyeliner glides on, creating intensely defined lines that can go from subtle to dramatic. Includes built-in sharpener for the perfect pointed tip and a smudger to blend.
- TWO FINISHES: Available in 12 totally wearable matte and shimmer shades
- OPHTHALMOLOGIST TESTED: Suitable for use on waterline and comfortable to wear
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is our best splurge pick, offering rich color that lasts all day. Its waterproof, smudge-proof formula ensures that your eyeliner stays put without fading. Compared to the NYX liquid option, this pencil is easier to apply and great for quick touch-ups. However, it may not achieve as fine a line as the liquid options. The tradeoff here is between ease of use and precision. While many find this pencil ideal for everyday wear, it might disappoint those seeking ultra-fine details.
Pros
- Long-lasting, waterproof formula
- Easy to apply with a pencil format
- Smudge-proof for all-day wear
Cons
- Not as precise as liquid options
- Can require sharpening
- Limited color options available
Best for: Everyday use and quick applications. Not ideal for: Those seeking ultra-fine application.
A convenient pencil for reliable, everyday wear.
3. Best Compact
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof Retractable Gel Eyeliner – Ultra Pigmented 16-Hour Long Wear, Smudge Proof Satin Finish Formula, Cruelty-Free &…
- Waterproof Eyeliner: This ultra pigmented eyeliner delivers smudge proof, flake proof, cry proof color with a satin gel formula that glides onto lids without tugging or pulling. Lasts up to 16 hours
- All Eyes On You: Our silky, waterproof retractable gel eyeliner is lightweight, comfortable, and ultra long lasting. Create bold looks effortlessly with the intense color rich formula
- Best Face Forward: From bronzer and blush to primer, highlighter, natural finish powder, and concealer, we’ve got you covered and photo ready for your next big thing. You’ve met your true makeup match
- Always Cruelty Free: We are 100% cruelty free and always have been. We also carry vegan makeup & tools such as foundation, nail polish, contour palettes, lipstick, makeup brushes and more
- Stay Wild: We are the trusted beauty destination for beauty lovers of all ages, ethnicities, skin colors, and economic statuses. No matter who or where you are in life, we have a product for you
- Fragrance-Free. Paraben-Free
Wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof Retractable Gel Eyeliner offers impressive wear time and pigmentation. This product glides smoothly and provides a satin finish. Compared to other eyeliners, it is lightweight and comfortable. While it lasts up to 16 hours, some users may find it doesn’t hold up as well as the NYX liner. The main limitation is that it may require touch-ups after a long day. However, it remains a good choice for those who want a balance of comfort and color.
Pros
- Ultra-pigmented for bold color
- Retractable design for easy use
- Smudge-proof and long-wearing
Cons
- May require touch-ups
- Less precise than liquid options
- Some may find it too soft
Best for: Users who want comfortable wear. Not ideal for: Those looking for maximum precision.
A solid choice for vibrant, comfortable wear.
4. Best for Small Spaces
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black
- ULTIMATE EYE PENCIL: The e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner is a waterproof, retractable eyeliner that checks all your pencil liner requirements
- ALL-DAY WEAR: This product is creamy, ultra-pigmented, and has ultimate waterproof staying power
- INTENSE LOOK: We recommend you use this retractable eyeliner pencil on your lash line, waterline, or all over the lid for intense eyes that last all day
- BEAUTY TIP: Apply all over the eyelid as a base for eyeshadow for an intense, dramatic, runway-inspired look
- VEGAN & CRUELTY-FREE: 100% vegan, e.l.f. is double-certified cruelty-free by Leaping Bunny & PETA.
E.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner is known for its creamy and ultra-pigmented formula. It provides bold and defined lines, making it easy to apply. Compared to the other eyeliners, this one is great for those who prefer a pencil format. However, it may not last as long as the waterproof options. Users looking for longevity may find this product lacking. Its creamy texture is great for beginners, but those seeking durability might want to consider other options.
Pros
- Creamy texture for smooth application
- Ultra-pigmented for bold color
- Retractable design avoids sharpening
Cons
- May not last as long as others
- Can smudge with excess moisture
- Less ideal for detailed looks
Best for: Beginners wanting easy application. Not ideal for: Users needing long-lasting wear.
A beginner-friendly pencil for bold, easy application.
5. Best Premium
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner – Ultra-Fine Brush, Waterproof, 16-Hour Long-Lasting Wear- Cruelty-Free & Vegan – Black
- Liquid Eyeliner: Our ultimate waterproof liquid liner provides smudge proof, flake proof, cry proof staying power. The ultra fine brush tip lets you create any look, from thin delicate lines to bold cat eyes
- All Eyes On You: This innovative eyeliner has a tank delivery system that allows the perfect flow of richly pigmented color with every application for precision, accuracy, and ease of application
- Best Face Forward: From bronzer and blush to primer, highlighter, natural finish powder, and concealer, we’ve got you covered and photo ready for your next big thing. You’ve met your true makeup match
- Always Cruelty Free: We are 100% cruelty free and always have been. We also carry vegan makeup & tools such as foundation, nail polish, contour palettes, lipstick, makeup brushes and more
- Stay Wild: We are the trusted beauty destination for beauty lovers of all ages, ethnicities, skin colors, and economic statuses. No matter who or where you are in life, we have a product for you
Wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner features a fine tip for precise application. Its waterproof formula stands out for its staying power. Compared to pencils, this liquid eyeliner can create much thinner lines. However, some users may find it tricky to apply without practice. The limitation lies in its learning curve, as beginners may struggle with application. For those willing to practice, it offers a bold look that lasts.
Pros
- Ultra-fine brush for precision
- Waterproof for all-day wear
- Highly pigmented for impact
Cons
- Requires practice for best application
- May not be suitable for beginners
- Can smudge if applied too thickly
Best for: Users seeking precise and bold looks. Not ideal for: Beginners unfamiliar with liquid liners.
A go-to for those mastering precise eyeliner application.
6. Best Lightweight
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 202 Black Brown, 0.01 oz
- LASTING EYELINER: Rich color looks freshly applied all day long; transfer-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof and fade-proof
- UP TO 24HR WEAR: Creates the look you want and stays on strong
- EASY APPLICATION: Pencil eyeliner glides on, creating intensely defined lines that can go from subtle to dramatic. Includes built-in sharpener for the perfect pointed tip and a smudger to blend.
- TWO FINISHES: Available in 12 totally wearable matte and shimmer shades
- OPHTHALMOLOGIST TESTED: Suitable for use on waterline and comfortable to wear
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner in 202 Black Brown offers a rich color option. This pencil is similar to its counterpart in 201 Black but provides a softer look. Compared to traditional black, this shade may suit those looking for something a little less intense. A key limitation is the consistency may not be as bold as others. However, it’s excellent for those who prefer a less dramatic appearance while still getting lasting wear.
Pros
- Soft, rich color for gentle looks
- Easy to apply and control
- Waterproof for long-lasting wear
Cons
- Less precise than liquid options
- Not as bold as black
- Limited in color variety
Best for: Users wanting softer eyeliner looks. Not ideal for: Those seeking a bold statement.
A gentle option for those who prefer subtlety.
7. Best Heavy-Duty
stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip | Lasting Satin Finish, Smudge-Proof & Transfer-Resistant
- Pull gently on the upper corner of the eye area to stretch and smooth the eye before lining with the Stay All Day Liquid Liner
- Apply the liner as close to the lashes as possible
- A product of the USA
- Goes on smoothly without skipping, smudging, or pulling
Stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner offers a fine brush tip, making it easy to apply. This eyeliner goes on smoothly without skipping, which is a significant advantage over some others. However, it may not last as long as other options. Users seeking extreme longevity might be disappointed. The main tradeoff here is between ease of application and wear time. For those who value precision, it is a great choice, even with its limitations.
Pros
- Fine brush tip for smooth lines
- Waterproof and smudge-proof
- Easy to apply without skipping
Cons
- May not last as long as others
- Can smudge if not dried properly
- More suitable for experienced users
Best for: Experienced users looking for precision. Not ideal for: Those needing all-day wear.
A precise tool for creating defined looks.
8. Most Versatile
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner – Ultra-Fine Brush, Waterproof,16-Hour Long-Lasting Wear – Cruelty-Free & Vegan – Black
- Waterproof Eyeliner: This ultra pigmented eyeliner delivers smudge proof, flake proof, cry proof color with a satin gel formula that glides onto lids without tugging or pulling. Lasts up to 16 hours
- All Eyes On You: Our silky, waterproof retractable gel eyeliner is lightweight, comfortable, and ultra long lasting. Create bold looks effortlessly with the intense color rich formula
- Best Face Forward: From bronzer and blush to primer, highlighter, natural finish powder, and concealer, we’ve got you covered and photo ready for your next big thing. You’ve met your true makeup match
- Always Cruelty Free: We are 100% cruelty free and always have been. We also carry vegan makeup & tools such as foundation, nail polish, contour palettes, lipstick, makeup brushes and more
- Stay Wild: We are the trusted beauty destination for beauty lovers of all ages, ethnicities, skin colors, and economic statuses. No matter who or where you are in life, we have a product for you
Wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner is known for its creamy application and 16-hour wear. This retractable format allows for easy use and portability. However, it may not provide the same staying power as liquid options. The limitation is in its longevity, which can be a dealbreaker for some. Still, it is a good choice for users who want comfort and ease while applying eyeliner.
Pros
- Creamy formula for easy application
- Retractable for convenience
- 16-hour wear time
Cons
- May require touch-ups
- Less precise than liquid options
- Not suitable for dramatic looks
Best for: Users wanting a comfortable, easy application. Not ideal for: Those desiring dramatic, long-lasting looks.
A convenient choice for easy, comfortable wear.
Eyeliners Compared Side by Side
The following table shows the eyeliner comparison. It includes key features like type, wear time, and ease of application. This will help you choose which product fits your needs best.
| # | Product | Best for | Brand | Price | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HR… | Editor's Choice | NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc. | $9.99 | Check |
| 2 | Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner | Best Splurge | Revlon | $11.38 | Check |
| 3 | wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof Retractable… | Best Compact | Markwins Beauty Brands | $2.28 | Check |
| 4 | e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner | Best for Small Spaces | e.l.f. Cosmetics | $6 | Check |
| 5 | wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner | Best Premium | Markwins Beauty Brands | $4.89 | Check |
| 6 | Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner | Best Lightweight | Revlon | $7.97 | Check |
| 7 | stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner | Best Heavy-Duty | Stila Styles, LLC | $18.99 | Check |
| 8 | wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner | Most Versatile | Markwins Beauty Brands | $2.28 | Check |
| 9 | Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner | — | Maybelline New York | $8.98 | Check |
| 10 | e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner | — | e.l.f. Cosmetics | $5.79 | Check |
Prices come from Amazon and change often. The price on Amazon at checkout is the one that applies.
How to Choose Eyeliners
Waterproof vs. Non-Waterproof
Waterproof eyeliners resist water, sweat, and humidity. They last longer than non-waterproof types. If you need an eyeliner for long wear, choose waterproof. But keep in mind that they may require a makeup remover for full removal.
Pencil vs. Liquid Eyeliner
Pencil eyeliners are easy to apply and great for beginners. Liquid eyeliners provide more precision and boldness. If you want a dramatic look, go for liquid. For everyday wear, a pencil may be better.
Wear Time
Some eyeliners offer longer wear than others. Look for products that guarantee 16 to 24 hours. This is important if you have a busy day ahead and need your makeup to last.
Color Options
Choose an eyeliner with colors that match your style. Black is classic, but browns and colored options can add fun. Consider your wardrobe to select colors that complement your outfits.
Application Ease
Some eyeliners have a precise tip for easy application. Look for features like a built-in sharpener or flexible brush. These can help you achieve the look you desire without much effort.
How We Reviewed
Where our data comes from
We gathered information from trusted beauty websites and product reviews. We looked at over 30 popular eyeliners to understand their features and user feedback. This ensured we had a good variety of options.
How we built this shortlist
We focused on eyeliners that have high ratings and good customer reviews. We compared features like waterproof ratings, wear time, and ease of use. Only the top-rated products made it to this list.
What we ruled out and why
Products with low ratings or negative user experiences were excluded from our shortlist. We also avoided eyeliners that did not offer a clear description of their specifications. This helped us focus on quality options.
What we did not do
We did not test any products by hand or perform lab measurements. All data was collected from reviews and product specifications. No scoring system was invented; all insights are based on available information.
How often this page is updated
This page will be updated regularly to include new eyeliners as they hit the market. We aim to refresh the content every few months or when significant new products are released.
Frequently asked questions
What should I look for in an eyeliner?
Look for waterproof formulas if you need long-lasting wear. Consider the application type, whether pencil or liquid, based on your skill level.
How do I apply liquid eyeliner?
Start by gently pulling the eyelid taut. Apply the eyeliner as close to the lash line as possible for a neat look.
What is the best eyeliner for beginners?
Pencil eyeliners are usually best for beginners. They are easier to control and can create subtle looks.
How long does eyeliner last?
Most eyeliners last between 8 to 24 hours. Look for products that specify their wear time for assurance.
Can I use eyeliner on my waterline?
Yes, but make sure to choose a safe formula for your waterline. Avoid products not meant for that area.
What to look for
Waterproof Quality
Waterproof eyeliners are essential for long-lasting wear. They resist smudging and fading, especially in humid conditions. If you need your eyeliner to last through the day, pick one that specifies waterproof qualities. Products like NYX and wet n wild excel in this area.
Pigmentation
Pigmentation refers to how rich and vibrant the color is. A highly pigmented eyeliner will appear bold and striking. For intense looks, opt for products that advertise high pigmentation, such as the wet n wild Mega Last line.
Application Tip
The tip of the eyeliner affects how easy it is to apply. Some have fine tips for precision, while others have thicker tips for bolder lines. If you’re new to eyeliner, a flexible tip can help you achieve better control.
Longevity
Some eyeliners claim to last for 16 to 24 hours. Check this feature to avoid mid-day touch-ups. Brands like Revlon and Stila focus on durability, making them great options for busy days.
Skin Type Consideration
Your skin type may affect how well an eyeliner performs. Oily eyelids may require waterproof formulas to prevent smudging. Dry skin might work well with creamier options. Always consider your skin type before making a choice.
Shopping around? We have 19 more eyeliner guides for other budgets and use cases.
Sources and standards
Background reading we checked while putting this guide together:
- NIH on botanical ingredients NCCIH (NIH)
- NIAMS skin health NIAMS (NIH)
About the author
Similar guides
- 8 Best Eyeliners under $100 in 2026 Beauty & Grooming
- 8 Best Eyeliners for Hot Weather in 2026 Beauty & Grooming
- 8 Best Eyeliners for Allergies in 2026 Beauty & Grooming
- 8 Best Candles for Camping in 2026 Beauty & Grooming
- Is Foundation Worth It: 8 Top Picks for 2026 Beauty & Grooming
- 8 Best Foundations under $20 in 2026 Beauty & Grooming
